Tuesday, August 4, 2009

A Trusted Cloud Entropy Authority

This is an incomplete thought, but I thought I'd take a moment to describe it a bit. In a recent article on Forbes a group of security researchers have brought to light one of the stranger problems that could potentially undermine cloud computing's cyber / cloud security, apparently it's not chaotic enough.
The forbes article describes "a presentation Thursday at the Black Hat cybersecurity conference in Las Vegas, iSec Partners researcher Alex Stamos pointed to what he described as a fundamental problem with cloud computing setups that use virtualization software to partition servers into "images," which are then rented out to customers. Although packing those virtual machines into cloud providers' data centers provides a more flexible and efficient setup than traditional servers, Stamos, along with fellow presenters Andrew Becherer and Nathan Wilcox, argued that virtual machines suffer from a rarely discussed flaw: They don't always have enough access to the random numbers needed to properly encrypt data"

Stamos goes on to state "operating system software typically monitors users' mouse movements and key strokes to glean random bits of data that are collected in a so-called "entropy pool," a set of unpredictable numbers that encryption software automatically pulls from to generate random encryption passkeys. In servers, which don't have access to a keyboard or mouse, random numbers are also pulled from the unpredictable movements of the computer's hard drive. If a malicious hacker were to set up his or her own Linux virtual machine in Amazon's EC2 cloud service, for example, he or she could use that machine's entropy pool to better guess at the entropy pools of other recently created Linux-based virtual servers in Amazon's cloud"
This is a very interesting problem. Although not specifically a cloud related it certainly could have implications for virtualization based infrastructure. One of the more insightful ideas to combat the lack of "entropy" comes from a comment on slashdot by Brian Gordon.

Gordon says "How about getting signed entropy from a trusted server on the network/internet?"

Gordon's comments did get me thinking, maybe there an opportunity to create a trusted cloud authority to provide signed verified and certified entropy. Think of it like a certificate authority (CA) but for chaos. Actually, Amazon Web Service itself could act as this entropy authority via a simple encrypted web service call. I even have a name for it, Simple Entropy Service (SES).

-- Update --
@Samj on twitter pointed me to a website called http://random.org a true random number service that generates randomness via atmospheric noise. Looks cool, maybe this may help solve the problem.

#DigitalNibbles Podcast Sponsored by Intel

If you would like to be a guest on the show, please get in touch.

Instagram